In all of its glory, here is the brutal call at home plate that ended Monday's Twins-Athletics game.
Cuddyer is safe in scoring the game-tying run, of course, but Mike Muchlinski, a Triple-A ump filling in for a vacationing major league counterpart, got himself in lousy position and blew the call.
What makes this particularly disgusting is that Muchlinski knew exactly what was materializing. He clearly took a peek towards third when Cuddyer was rounding the bag -- he knew there was going to be a play at home -- yet he still did his best Brandon Phillips imitation while loafing over to where he was in an awful position to make the game-determining call.
And the positioning is as much of a problem as the laziness. It's ridiculous how often umpires let themselves be screened on plays at the plate. Unfortunately, the best place to make those calls from would be in fair territory, right at the top of the circle. We never see umpires there, though, and for good reason most of the time. Still, wouldn't it make a lot more sense to set up on the first-base line except when the throw is coming in from right field? Muchlinski doesn't blow that call if he's three feet to the right. He probably wouldn't have blown it if he was a couple of feet to the left, as he would have had a better view between Michael Wuertz's legs. Delmon Young, the hitter on the wild pitch, has no formal training and was in a much better position to see the play.
Muchlinski, though, didn't set up anywhere. He was still moving even as the tag wasn't being made. He only stopped to make his impressively elaborate out call, complete with the arched-back load-up and powerful right hook to the ground. It was the type of punch out that's sure to get him noticed if MLB ever again hires a full-time ump. He'll certainly have A's fans on his side.
.



Reminded me a little of the phantom-tag controversy with Jeter a while back, in that the throw seemed to beat the runner, but the tag clearly did not. The umpires often don't seem to care much about the tagging part of these plays, and it's become an annoying trend. A brutal loss for Twins fans all around.
Yeah - I stayed up watching the game and though the Twins lost the game fourteen other ways besides that call - that it was so terribly blown was a bad way to end a long night.
Wow, Mathew, have you ever umpired? You sure do seem to be an expert on positioning, etc. And I don't mean 6 year olds at the YMCA, I mean big guys. I'll bet you would be real good at it.
Exactly what part of my argument are you disagreeing with? That he was in good position?
No, I've never umped. It's surely not an easy job, and I don't envy the guys who have to stand out there for three hours a night and take that kind of abuse. However, that doesn't mean they don't deserve to be called out when they blow it. It wasn't just that he made the wrong call... it was what he did that led to him making the wrong call.
How about the Twins bullpen blowing a 10-run lead against the worst offensive team in the A.L? Maybe the Twins should ought to take a closer look at that. had the bullpen took care of business, the game would not have come down to one (bad) call at the end of the game
I think the point here is that umps need to be held accountable when they make bad calls.
It doesn't matter what the situation was, that ump blew the call, plain and simple. They need to expand instant replay to situations like that. I'm not talking about reviewing balls and strikes, but clearly a replay would've fixed last night's mistake.
See: Causey, Kevin, Umpire, Replacement
From
From -
Sorry the Twins bullpen was bad but the starter (Blackburn) gave up some of those runs as well (The Twins lead 12-2 in the 3rd) Making a bad call is human error, being out of position as Muchlinski was is inexcusable for a big league ump. The NFL fines refs on bad calls that the league office later reviews, perhaps MLB should do likewise because you are right, that was a horrendous call.